I made (with lots of help from Sara and Eliza) some super easy cupcakes with "poopoh" frosting. Blowing out the candles was a big hit this year. I think she did it at least 5 times. And then she did it twice later at her party with all of my family. (Then she requested cookie cupcakes)
Eliza also adored opening presents. Her two favorites seemed to be ducks from my parents and the slide (we are using it indoors) from us. Her sisters got her an ice cream parlor (Sara) and a dress-up skirt (Laura).